Skip to main content

Happy Birthday Superman - here's a throwback to one of the most depressing birthday comics of all time

For the Man Who Has Everything may be the most haunting birthday story ever

Superman with the Black Mercy attached to his chest
Image credit: DC Comics

Popverse is taking a brief pause beginning Thursday, July 11, as we not only prepare for SDCC 2024, but also put the finishing touches behind the scenes on a new website platform to continue delivering news, interviews, guides, and more about comics, tv, movies and conventions, the best way we know how. Learn more here.

Popverse's top stories of the day

Birthdays are expected to be a happy occassion. And we're happy to celebrate the spectacular Superman as he turns one year older on February 29, but it also seems like a good time to celebrate one of the best (and most depressing) birthday comics ever made.

Yes, we're talking about Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons' iconic story 'For the Man Who Has Everything,' originally published in Superman Annual #11. Superman fans who aren't into reading comics from the 80s might still recognize the title, as the story was famously adapted for Justice League Unlimited cartoon in 2004 and again adapted (but this time for Kara, instead of Kal-El) in an episode of Supergirl.

In 'For the Man Who Has Everything,' we follow Batman, Wonder Woman, and Jason Todd as they head to Superman's place bearing birthday gifts for their friend. When they find Superman though, they are shocked to see that he's got some sort of organism attached to his chest. They soon learn, from supervillain Mongul, that the organism is called the Black Mercy, and that, when attached to someone, will hold them in a state where their deepest desire comes true.

Superman, when attached to the Black Mercy, is brought to a life where he grew up on Krypton, got married, had a son. To return to the real world (and save Batman and Wonder Woman who are struggling in a battle with Mongul, who had sent the Black Mercy to Superman), Superman must leave his son and the life that he desires most deeply behind. This drives him into a fury, powering him to beat Mongul and plan to drop the villain into a black hole for what he's done.

It's a tragic story, and a reminder of the sad core at the center of Superman's story. But still, Superman's got friends. Wonder Woman gifts him with a replica of Kandor, and Batman has brought him a flower - a new breed of rose that he's named Krypton, though the rose has been destroyed during the fight.

Happy birthday, Superman.

Get into the vibrant world of comics with our guide to buying digital comics, how to make the most out of comic shops, our comprehensive guide to the upcoming comics, manga, and graphic novels you should be looking for, and everything you need to know about Free Comic Book Day and Local Comic Shop Day.

Follow Popverse for upcoming event coverage and news

Tiffany Babb avatar
Tiffany Babb: Tiffany Babb is a professional lurker (aka critic) who once served as Popverse’s deputy editor and resident Sondheim enthusiast.
Related topics
Featured events