If you click on a link and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. Read our editorial policy.
ABC's Lost originally killed Jorge Garcia's Hurley in the pilot, and Josh Holloway's Sawyer did it (and was scared to do it)
Lost almost began with Sawyer accidentally causing Hurley’s death

Popverse's top stories
- Critical Role star Sam Riegel didn't know FCG's fate before the moment happened - but he did know it was "a good way to go"
- X-Men actress Famke Janssen doesn’t own an action figure of herself as Jean Grey, because they don’t look like her
- DC's Batman #1 has already outsold 2024's best-selling comic of the year
And everything happening this week for Future Fest!
Hugo 'Hurley' Reyes appeared in 107 episodes of Lost. He was one of the only castaways to survive all six seasons. In fact, the series ends with Hurley becoming the new guardian of the island. It’s an interesting journey for a character that was initially planned to be killed in the first episode. The original story treatment for the Lost pilot had Hurley falling to his death from a cliff after Sawyer was unable to pull him up. Not only would this have drastically changed the course of the series, but it also would’ve made it hard for the audience to get behind Sawyer.
“In the original pilot, they had me drop Jorge [Garcia] and he died,” Sawyer actor Josh Holloway says during a Florida Supercon panel. “I was like, ‘I’m dead. First season.’ You don’t come back from that. Luckily, a new script came in, and that was not in it. But he was, like you said, a bit of an a-hole. And so, I fought for any humanity I could find in him. So that letter, I was like, ‘Oh fuck, this could save me.’ I really leaned into his humanity, because it was very little in the beginning, and they let that grow, luckily.”
Josh Holloway’s charisma went a long way into making Sawyer a lovable character. But would that have been enough to make the audience forgive him for dropping Hurley? Thankfully, we’ll never have to know.
You can watch the full Lost panel from Florida Supercon 2025 here.
Here's how to watch Lost in order.
About Florida Supercon 2025
Florida Supercon brings your favorite celebrities, unique exhibitors, incredible comic creators, anime voice actors, gaming, wrestling, and more under one roof in sunny Miami Beach for an incredible weekend celebrating the very best pop culture has to offer.
Dates
-
Location
Miami Beach
United States of America
Follow Popverse for upcoming event coverage and news
Find out how we conduct our review by reading our review policy
Let Popverse be your tour guide through the wilderness of pop culture
Sign in and let us help you find your new favorite thing.

Comments
Want to join the discussion? Please activate your account first.
Visit Reedpop ID if you need to resend the confirmation email.