If you click on a link and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. Read our editorial policy.

What do you think of the upkeep step in MTG? Some of the people who make the game regret creating it, and have been slowly de-prioritizing it

Head of game design at Magic: The Gathering, Mark Rosewater, isn't sure that upkeep would remain in Magic if the game were created today

Taryn Knight's art for Bitterbloom Bearer from Magic: The Gathering
Image credit: Wizards of the Coast

When you learn how to play Magic: The Gathering, you learn the various phases that make up a single turn in the game. The second part of the beginning phase of your turn is called upkeep, and you would be forgiven (by me at least) if you admitted that you forget about it sometimes. 

Folks who have been playing Magic since the game's early days have a more solid understanding of it because older sets of the game featured more cards that had abilities that were triggered specifically during upkeep. That isn't to say that upkeep is completely gone from newer Magic sets, as the upcoming Lorwyn Eclipsed set's Bitterbloom Bearer card can attest to, but it's a phase that Magic: The Gathering designers have consciously been moving away from in recent years. 

The head of game design at Magic: The Gathering, Mark Rosewater, revealed on his Tumblr blog that the game's Research & Design department (commonly abbreviated as "R&D") "has decided start of first main phase is just a better place to have a trigger than upkeep. If we started Magic over, I don't even know if the game would have upkeep. I might do a podcast on the topic." Please create a podcast episode about this, MaRo. 

Case in point: I was playing Magic: The Gathering this weekend with the Avatar: The Last Airbender Beginner Box, a bundle designed to be as newcomer-friendly as possible. I don't remember upkeep factoring into any of the matches I played with my buddy, but take my memory with a grain of salt. I just flipped through the cards I got from two Avatar collector's packs, and none of them featured an upkeep trigger. So there is that. 

Obviously, given that Lorwyn Eclipsed will have at least one card with an upkeep trigger, the step in the beginning phase isn't going to vanish immediately from the game in the near future at this point in time. But perhaps it will slowly fade away into obscurity, like many other things that were invented in the 1990s. 


Whether you are a Commander player, a regular at your local game shop's FNM event, or simply love collecting Magic: The Gathering cards, you've landed in the right place. From Universes Beyond to the furthest reaches of the Magic Multiverse, we've got you covered here at Popverse. 

Jules Chin Greene

Jules Chin Greene: Jules Chin Greene is a journalist and Jack Kirby enthusiast. He has written about comics, video games, movies, and television for sites such as Nerdist, AIPT, and Multiverse of Color.

Comments

Want to join the discussion? Please activate your account first.
Visit Reedpop ID if you need to resend the confirmation email.

View Comments (0)

Find out how we conduct our review by reading our review policy