If you click on a link and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. Read our editorial policy.

The pop culture of all things: Chatting with proprietors of NYC comic shops at NYCC 2022

New York Comic Con features booths from some of the best comic shops in the city. We had a chance to chat with them.
Photograph of interior of Javits center during NYCC 2022 featuring people walking
Reedpop

Popverse: What’s special about running a comic book shop in New York City, as opposed to other places around the world?

Gerry Gladston, Midtown Comics: Luckily, New York City is constantly featured in all of pop culture: movies, TV, books, comics… Marvel! All the Marvel comic books take place in New York City. So when people come into New York City, and they’re interested in pop culture and all that stuff, they’re gonna hit the landmarks. And we’re the biggest landmark in Times Square when it comes to pop culture and comic books.

Nick Giangarra of St. Mark’s Comics: New York City is sort of the center of the universe, so you’ve gotta be everything to everybody. That’s sort of what we specialize in. We carry almost everything that’s published, and we carry almost every genre under the moon, you know? It’s all here. Figures and statues and all of it. We do it all!

Jimmy Chen of Montasy Comics: You see a combination of all people from around the world, as well as all the different people from the United States, because folks come over and take a look. So you get locals, you get guys that are from the states, and then you get guys from all over the world. We’ve had guys from Japan, Europe… Boston… Pennsylvania [laughs]. So it’s really cool to see the different interests, and what excites them.

Interior image of Midtown Comics featuring comics and tshirts and toys for sale

How does running a booth like this at New York Comic Con differ from a typical Wednesday at the regular shop?

Midtown Comics: [Laughs] Honestly, the only difference between being in the regular shop shopping, and in here shopping, is there’s no new releases. That’s the only difference. Other than that, just owning this booth and having this booth here is like having another shop for a few days.

St. Mark’s Comics: New York Comic Con is different in that it’s infinitely more people, all in the same day. It’s a lot of the same stuff but just on a bigger scale. It’s the same as what we do every week, just faster. There’s less time to interact with every customer personally, less time to get to know who you’re selling stuff to. But we like to think that we can make the same sort of recommendations that we do in the shop.

Montasy Comics: I think when you’re talking about NYCC, it’s sort of like the pop culture of all things, right? So when you’re exhibiting it versus Wednesday, Wednesday may be about “oh, what’s coming out? What are the new comics?” It’s more comics-specific and comics-centric. New York Comic Con, yes, it is comics as well, but like I said it’s more pop culture. So that allows folks who are into comics, or the comics-related, to see a lot more things. That’s where you’re seeing people who are into Spider-Man, but more from a movie, more from a toy, more from collecting [perspective], but not necessarily the comics.

Photograph of a spinner rack featuring Little Golden Books with superheroes on them

What’s something unique about your store that makes it stand out from other comic book shops?

Midtown Comics: I don’t wanna talk out of turn [laughs] but we always keep the customer in mind. And we never gouge them. So we never jack up prices on signed books. Anyone could tell you that when you buy a signed book from us, it’s cover price. Unless it’s a back issue, or it became, like, a Something is Killing the Children #1, we’re not gonna jack up the price on something like that. So whenever we do a stock signing and get like a thousand, two thousand pieces, we never raise that price. The most we’ll raise it is like a dollar, within a couple of weeks. But we don’t gouge the customer. We’ve very customer-friendly and customer-based.

St. Mark’s Comics: I would like to think that our vast selection, the spread of what we carry with everything that’s published, but also that we do vintage stuff, which a lot of the other guys don’t do anymore. So we’ve got vintage toys, vintage comics… probably going back to the 1930s at this point. We’ve even got toys going back to the 1950s. So we do just an incredible spread of stuff.

Montasy Comics: Leading into what we talked about with pop culture, we pretty much carry all products. Meaning, you’re looking at it from Funko, from comics, from trading card games, from sports cards, entertainment cards… where people are surprised by the breadth of product we have, and we still have vintage comics, recent comics, and all the other things. So a family goes in, and they go in different directions. “I want to do this, I want comics, I want Funko, I want trading cards.” So that to us is very different, because other comic shops typically carry comics and a little bit of other things. Whereas we’re fairly evenly distributed with our products.


Comic book stores can be intimidating-- especially for beginners. But have no fear! Check out this Popverse article: How do I comic shop?
Did you miss this year's NYCC? Or maybe you simply want to revisit it! Check out Popverse's roundup of all of our coverage (including streaming panels) of this year's New York Comic Con.

ARE YOU ENJOYING POPVERSE?

Do you want more fandom news that's actually about your fandoms? That's what we're here for.

Subscribe to Popverse and get:

  • An ad-free viewing experience
  • Access to members-only articles
  • Access to our on-demand video library of panels and programs from live events
  • Access to exclusive presales for live event tickets to NYCC, MCM, ECCC & C2E2
  • An exclusive member gift

Membership starts at $65 / £45 per year.

About the Author
Greg Silber avatar

Greg Silber

Contributing writer

GREGORY PAUL SILBER (but you can call him Greg) is a Brooklyn-based writer, editor, and critic specializing in comic books and entertainment. His work has appeared in outlets like The Daily Dot, Shelfdust, NeoText, the Eisner award-winning PanelxPanel, and The Beat, home to his “Silber Linings” humor column. A mild-mannered copywriter by day, Greg is also a comic book writer, a freelance comic book editor, and can often be found hosting trivia at Brooklyn bars. He loves horror movies, rock concerts, and thinking about the time Grant Morrison complimented his work.

Comments
Popverse logo

Around here we know a collection is never really complete

We've got the best products and exclusives in gaming, anime, comics, and more, all in one place.

Shop the Haul and see what you’re missing
Popverse Merch