If you click on a link and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. Read our editorial policy.
How fan complaints to Gwen Stacy's shocking death in Amazing Spider-Man led Marvel to the ill-fated Clone Saga
Stan Lee and Marvel Comics weren't ready for how hard Gwen Stacy’s death would hit fans, and backlash led to something worse: the Clone Saga.

Popverse's top stories
- The Boys boss sounds off against fans complaining about Season 5 'filler': "You're just watching the wrong show."
- Dimension 20 as a play-at-home game? Dropout's Sam Reich says it's in the works
- An anti-spy thriller is coming from Image Comics that's equal parts The Kingsman and K-Pop Demon Hunters
Nobody was prepared for the backlash when Gwen Stacy died, especially Stan Lee. Peter Parker’s longtime girlfriend was killed by the Green Goblin in Amazing Spider-Man #121, and fans were not happy. Marvel was flooded with letters from angry fans, and Stan Lee was accosted during public appearances. This caused Lee, who was Marvel’s publisher at the time, to publicly disown the story.
“Stan did not say no to this,” Amazing Spider-Man #121 writer, the late Gerry Conway, said during a spotlight panel at San Diego Comic Con 2013. “I mean, Stan was fine with it. He was like, ‘Yeah, okay. Go kill her.’ But Stan did get a lot of heat at conventions and at college campuses, and as a result of that started claiming that it happened when he had been out of the office and didn’t know. And he asked us to bring her back, which led to a whole other set of stories.”
Conway and Roy Thomas, Marvel’s editor-in-chief, thought it would be cheap to undo Gwen’s death, so they searched for a compromise that would appease their agitated publisher.
“Stan wanted to bring back Gwen Stacy. None of us wanted to bring back the real Gwen Stacy. And I said, ‘Well, how about if I bring her back as a clone, and then can I get rid of her right away.’ Stan said sure, and that’s the direction we took.”
“Stan did sort of shift the blame off onto me and onto Roy and the other people at the office, and that’s why he asked us to bring Gwen back. I think to our credit, and I will credit Roy a lot on this as the editor, we didn’t. We brought back a version of her, but it wasn’t her, and it was very clearly not her, and she never came back into the books. I think she’s the only major character in comics who’s ever been killed off who has never come back. And I think that’s one of the reasons she’s an icon.”
However, Lee’s request to bring Gwen Stacy back had unintended consequences. As Conway wrote the issues introducing Gwen Stacy’s clone, he wondered what it would be like if there were other clones.
“As I was working on it I realized, well, wouldn’t it be kind of fun if we end up with Peter having to fight himself as a clone.”
And thus, the original Spider-Man Clone Saga was born. The story would have a controversial follow-up in the ‘90s, which also inspired its own series of angry letters (albeit for different reasons). It’s funny to think all the drama surrounding Ben Reilly and the Clone Saga happened because Stan Lee was tired of angry college students.
Marvel's most reliable superhero has proven he can do a whole lot more than just 'whatever a spider can.' Swing into Spidey's history with Popverse's...
- Best Spider-Man comic books
- The best Spider-Mans (or is it Spider-Men?)
- Spider-Man movie watch order
- Spider-Man's actors, ranked
- The best Spider-Man suits
- and the Spider-verse explained!
Just watch out for that radioactive blood.
About Popverse Spotlight: Spider-Man
Listen, bud... Spider-Man is the definition of a modern superhero. From his comic books to his TV shows, movies, games, and more, he is the epitome of the superhero genre — even without a cape! In Popverse Spotlight: Spider-Man, we celebrate all the facets of Marvel's wallcrawler, across all major media, and even include other people who have been Spider-Man in addition to Peter Parker. Face it tiger, you just hit the jackpot!
Dates
-
Location
Popverse
Follow Popverse for upcoming event coverage and news
Find out how we conduct our review by reading our review policy
Let Popverse be your tour guide through the wilderness of pop culture
Sign in and let us help you find your new favorite thing.
















Comments
Want to join the discussion? Please activate your account first.
Visit Reedpop ID if you need to resend the confirmation email.