If you click on a link and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. Read our editorial policy.

The Daryl & Carol reunion was a long time coming, according to The Walking Dead: Daryl Dixon creators

"Is it a little manipulative of us?" asks The Walking Dead: Daryl Dixon executive producer Greg Nicotero of the choice to keep the best pals apart for so long, "Yeah"

Fans didn't demand too much of The Walking Dead: Daryl Dixon - seeing Norman Reedus kick some zombie ass in a post-apocalyptic Paris was basiclaly enough for them. However, there was one event for which they kept their hopes high - the reunion of Daryl Dixon and bets buddy Carol Peletier (AKA Melissa McBride). Most fans finally got to see that reunion on October 20, when Daryl Dixon season 2, episode 4 aired on AMC, but if you were lucky enough to be at the Daryl Dixon panel at New York Comic Con 2024, you got to see it a little early. 

And you got to find out why the hell it took so long.

OK, let's back up for a sec. The NYCC panel we're talking about featured a host of special guests on stage to chat about The Walking Dead's Franc-based spinoff. Included on the panel were showrunner David Zabel, executive producer Greg Nicotero, Carol Peletier actor McBride, Daryl Dixon himself, Norman Reedus, and the most special guest of them all: eight-year-old Matteo, a Walking Dead superfan and cancer survivor, who was on stage for NYCC courtesy of the Make-A-Wish foundation. 

At the halfway point of the panel, the crew showed the panel's attendee's a sneak peak of Daryl Dixon season 2, episode 4, which ended in the reunion of Daryl and Carol, whose friendship was a fan-favorite of the original Walking Dead series. Asked what he thought of the episode, young Matteo explained that he "didn't think it would take that long" for the pair to reunite.

The audience found this pretty funny, as did showrunner Zabel, who offered Matteo a spot in the Daryl Dixon writer's room (keep that footage, kid, it may get you a job someday). When the fun died down, however, Nicotero jumped in to explain to the audience why the moment took so long to happen in the show.

"That's almost like saying,"  "'They should have found Sophia in episode 2 of season 2.'"

(Author's note: Sophia is Carol's missing daughter, who motivated much of the character's choices in the early seasons of TWD.)

"You have to earn it," Nicotero said of story moments that big, "You have to build to it. That moment of Sophia coming out of the barn is really what solidified The Walking Dead as a Powerhouse television show.

(Another author's note: Look up what happens with Sophia in the barn yourself, I'm not hear to explain TV to you.)

"What Norman said and what Melissa said," Nicotero continued, "Is if we would have just done it right away, you wouldn't have had the same emotional reaction. Is it a little manipulative of us? Yeah. But that's why you watch the show! So just get on board with us."

"I've been in The Walking Dead Universe for almost 16 years," the longtime Walking Dead vet concludes, "And I still love what we do in the stories that we tell. [...] That moment was earned, and if it would have happened too soon, you wouldn't have had the same response."

Well said, Greg. Way to stick it to that eight-year-old. 

The Walking Dead: Daryl Dixon is streaming now on Netflix.


Join the zombie horde with Popverse's Walking Dead watch order. 

About New York Comic Con

Welcome home, hero. This is your event where you can feel unafraid to geek out. Where you’re accepted and embraced for being yourself, regardless of your cultural background, physical ability, personal identity, or self-expression. Where you can experience the best in pop culture, be inspired, get star struck, treat yourself, and create all of those memories with the people you care about the most.

Dates

-

Location

Jacob Javits Convention Center
USA

Visit the event page
×
Grant DeArmitt

Grant DeArmitt: Grant DeArmitt (he/him) likes horror, comics, and the unholy union of the two. As Popverse's Staff Writer, he criss-crosses the pop culture landscape bringing you the news and opinions about the big things (and the next big things). In the past, and despite their better judgment, he has written for Nightmare on Film Street and Newsarama. He lives in Brooklyn with his partner, Kingsley, and corgi, Legs.

Comments

Want to join the discussion? Please activate your account first.
Visit Reedpop ID if you need to resend the confirmation email.

View Comments (0)

Find out how we conduct our review by reading our review policy